Woman Takes Plea Deal in Boise Prison Break Case

A woman implicated in aiding two men after a dramatic prison escape and hospital shooting in Boise has entered a plea deal, agreeing to testify against the two suspects. Tonia Huber, 53, pleaded guilty to charges of harboring a wanted felon and possession of a controlled substance, Twin Falls County court records reveal. As part of the agreement, prosecutors dropped a prior charge of eluding police in exchange for Huber's cooperation in testifying against Skylar Meade and Nicholas Umphenour, the primary suspects in the incident.

Events Leading to the Arrests

The case stems from a chaotic series of events on March 20, 2024, when Meade, an Idaho Department of Correction (IDOC) inmate, was transported to Saint Alphonsus Hospital for treatment of self-inflicted wounds. IDOC staff accompanied Meade, with two officers in the ambulance and additional armed personnel following behind.

As the medical treatment concluded and officers prepared to transport Meade back to prison, another man, identified as Nicholas Umphenour, opened fire on the officers. The shooting left three officers injured, with one in critical but stable condition, another with serious but non-life-threatening injuries, and a third treated for minor injuries sustained during the incident. Following the attack, both Meade and Umphenour fled the scene, setting off a statewide manhunt.

The Capture of Meade, Umphenour, and Huber's Role

On March 21, Meade was apprehended in Twin Falls County after a brief vehicle pursuit. Huber was driving the vehicle at the time of Meade's arrest and was charged with eluding authorities and drug possession. Umphenour was captured the same day, and both men are now under investigation for possible involvement in two northern Idaho homicides in Clearwater and Nez Perce counties.

Huber's role in aiding the escape has drawn significant attention, particularly as prosecutors build their case against Meade and Umphenour. Her plea deal, which requires her to “testify truthfully at all court hearings,” is a critical element in the prosecution's strategy to secure convictions against the two men.

The Legal Ramifications for Huber

While Huber's plea deal has resulted in the dismissal of her eluding charge, she still faces sentencing for the remaining charges of harboring a wanted felon and possession of a controlled substance. Both charges carry serious consequences, although her cooperation with authorities may lead to a more lenient sentence. Her sentencing hearing is scheduled for January 24, 2025, at which time the court will determine the extent of her punishment.

Broader Implications of the Case

This case highlights the complexity and ripple effects of aiding and abetting criminal activity, particularly when the crimes involve violence and public safety threats. For individuals facing similar charges, the outcomes hinge not only on the evidence presented but also on their willingness to cooperate with authorities. Huber's plea deal demonstrates how defendants can negotiate reduced charges in exchange for providing testimony critical to the prosecution's case.

The case also underscores the severe consequences of violent actions against law enforcement and the coordinated efforts required to apprehend suspects in high-profile incidents. As Meade and Umphenour face additional investigations for possible homicides, this case continues to reveal a broader pattern of criminal activity that law enforcement agencies are working to unravel.

What's Next?

As Huber prepares for sentencing, prosecutors will likely rely heavily on her testimony to strengthen their case against Meade and Umphenour. The cooperation agreement ensures that Huber plays a pivotal role in holding the primary suspects accountable while allowing her to potentially mitigate her own legal consequences.

For Meade and Umphenour, the stakes remain high. Their charges not only involve the hospital shooting and escape but could also expand significantly if evidence links them to the Clearwater and Nez Perce County homicides. This case is expected to draw attention through its conclusion, given its complexity and implications for criminal justice in Idaho.

Facing Serious Charges? Attorneys of Idaho Can Help

If you are navigating the legal system and facing significant charges, don't wait to secure your defense. Contact Attorneys of Idaho today for a consultation and let our experienced attorneys fight to protect your future.